Libby = an Other..??

[lord-of-da-FELIX]

I dunno, but it seems pretty possible you know. Libby magically ran into Desmond at the coffeshop and Cindy thing was also suspicious. maybe she had a hand in Cindy's disappearance... and being in the same asylum as Hurley.. very suspicious. maybe she's keeping an eye on him? or maybe she's related to the widmores somehow...

i don't like the idea of Libby being an Other , but this site made me think otherwise

[Michelle]

i no what you mean, theres something decidedly fishy about her, she does seem to be the one with the most connections ot everyone else and we know shes lieing to hurley about where he recognised her from, so who knows libby could be anything,

[Red Matrix]

She could *have* been.

[Harlzard]

hmmm, i always thought she wasn't. Just didn't seem right to think she was one. She has had plenty of opotunities to steal that baby i reckon too.

[lord-of-da-FELIX]

maybe she's not one of them Others.. the Others are obviously not interested in stealing Aaron (they could've done that way earlier)..she could be somehow working for the Widmores or the Paik company? i mean, why else would she give away her sailboat that her husband left for her?

okay, let's just assume that there's nothing suspicious with libby. forget that there's anything wrong with her. start with the evidence - one: sailboat thing is very suspicious. and coincidentally, des crashed on the island via sailboat. maybe the boat's rigged? two: the cindy thing, libby was the last who saw her. three: she supported ana in throwing nathan into the pit. now that's definitely suspicious... let's just say there's more to libby than meets the eye.. there's definitely something wrong with that woman

[Red Matrix]

Felix, have you finished season 2?

[Harlzard]

hang on, what season are you currently viewing? this could be confusing me a bit. I have seen to the end of season 2. i just want to brng up any spoilers and vise versa.

But, thats some good points Lord.

[lord-of-da-FELIX]

yeah I've watched until the end of season 2.. and i know that libby was on the plane too (there was a brief encounter with mr eko at the airport) but that doesn't rule that she may be more than what she seems.

anyway libby's coming back for season 3 so maybe it'll shed some light on this libby thing....

[Red Matrix]

Spoiler:

show spoiler

How could Libby be an Other, if she's dead?

[lord-of-da-FELIX]

yup libby's dead. but it doesn't mean that she's not an other or used to work for the widmores. lots of others get killed all the time too.

see, the thing im sayin is: theres something shady going on with libby, and we don't know what; we can only speculate. she's dead, yeah, on the island but **spoiler** she will reappear in season 3 in someone's flashback (says the producers) that'll hopefully explain what's her deal.