hurely

[Lux_Mundi]

Originally Posted by furst

Except now she's dead, so I don't really see the point in that whole thing. It's like the writers wanted to do something big on her, but realized tying her previous life in with Hurley would be too complicated... maybe not though, we'll see.

Yeah, the whole Libby tie-in wasn't the most integral element to the show, after all.

[Michelle]

maybe it will prove to be important later in the series who knows?

[Lux_Mundi]

Originally Posted by Michelle

maybe it will prove to be important later in the series who knows?

Good point.

[Michelle]

from what iv seen everything on the show has a meaning therefore libby bein in the same mental hospital will probaly have some form of meaning later on, it would be pretty pointless them showing us otherwise and a waste of time, unless of course it is a way to confuse us about whats really going on

[kermit]

something tells me they wouldn't make a mistake that big... either there's still more to that story, or there's going to be a lot of unanswered questions other than this and the fact that they're unanswered will be a part of the plot itself :P

[mjrisin]

I was thinking that Libby is/was an "other". Her significance is to show that the others were present in the real world lives of the survivors, most likely observing them.

[kermit]

Originally Posted by mjrisin

I was thinking that Libby is/was an "other". Her significance is to show that the others were present in the real world lives of the survivors, most likely observing them.

that makes a lot of sense... why she was at the psyche ward watching hurley... why she gave the boat to desmond so easily... why she lied to hurley when he said he thought he knew her... has there been any proof that she was actually even on the plane? i don't remember seeing her in any of the sydney/airport flashbacks

[Harlzard]

thats a good theory, it does make a lot of sense. i havnt seen the episodes that far yet, last one i saw was when he nearly fell off the cliff but i have had my thoughs on whether she was on the plane or not.
you don't really see much of her too.

[Michelle]

Originally Posted by kermit

has there been any proof that she was actually even on the plane? i don't remember seeing her in any of the sydney/airport flashbacks

she was in the airport at the eko flashback when the girl was givin him the message from ekos brother

[kermit]

Originally Posted by Michelle

she was in the airport at the eko flashback when the girl was givin him the message from ekos brother

damn, ok ;P yeah i don't think she was one of the others, i think maybe she was following hurley for other reasons...