Are Desmond, Locke, and Eko alive?

[The Lost Man]

Your thoughts? If Charlie got out, could they?

[Lost Eternal]

I'm thinking Eko is dead, and Locke is seriously wounded. Perhaps fatally.

[Lpspider]

Originally Posted by Lost Eternal

I'm thinking Eko is dead, and Locke is seriously wounded. Perhaps fatally.

Lost Eternal, is there any particular reason you think this? Or is it just some wild guess?

Personally, I think Eko, Locke, and obviously Desmond are all dead. They were all inside as far as we could tell by the footage. I think Charlie acted that way because he was in a sort of state of shock or something.