React to 2.18 "Dave"

[Sydney]

React to "Dave"

Tell us what you loved, hated, liked, etc.

To vote you must be a member.

Not a Member?
Register Here

[adelledais]

I knew that it couldn't be all in Hurly's head, but when it turns out that Libby was in the same crazy house as Hurly, it confused me. Is it somesort of crazy house conspiracy?

It was an okay episode, but I expected abit more since last's weeks was great. My favourite part was when Jin just stood there while Hurly was beating up Sawyer :lol: .

[joules89]

The jig is up for Henry or whatever he deems it necesssary to call himself. I have to know if Sayid would have relly shot Henry if it wasn't for the intervention of Ana Lucia. I hate that she stopped Sayid because henry was about to spill the beans on the 'he' that is so powerful that would kill him worse then I guess Sayid was five seconds away from doing. It seems that the Hurley and Libby have a stronger connection that seems to make things very intresting (can't wait to see that unfold), but wouldn't that also mean that she would recognize the numbers because she probably knows leonard. What was she committed for? If Henry is a liar how can we trust what he tells Locke or anyone else. He has a big hidden agenda watch out.

[Fair_Monitor]

I thought it was a great episode actually. I mean yes last weeks was rather exciting but the final minute of this weeks with the slow pan around to psycho Libby certainly did catch me off guard. The dave side story was interesting and yet sort of apparent. After movies like 6th Sense and Fight Club (both of which I love) it seemed a little obvious that he wasn't real. Regardless still good in my opinion and the Henry story is continuing rather nicely. Personally I strongly believe that Sayid would have probably just shot Henry's arm off or something, he wouldn't be stupid enough to actually kill their only chance to find the Others. I was honestly more confused by Henry's comments towards God, the entire "Even God can't see this island" that was sorta...weird. And the hatch being fake, hard to say.

[nationoflost]

i thought the episode was really good. i'm wondering if sayid and ana-lucia secretly planned on playing good-cop / bad-cop. i think that nutcase libby is gonna throw a big wrench in the losties' gear. i read somewhere (before the "Dave" episode airred) that libby was a pathological liar. but, by the way she looked in the hospital, i think lying is/was just one thing on a list of things that are wrong with her. didn't she claim that she was a pshychologist? hhmmmm..... makes you wonder what else she's lying about and/or not telling. we probably won't find out for some time about the result of this whole libby situation.

[ObsessedWithSawyer13]

WARNING: the following post contains extreme bragging & includes me acting like a know-it-all. Do not read if you can not stand ppl like me.

Hey! wasn't there a theroy that said that they were all crazy & that the island was all in their mind? & wasn't there a theroy that said that the numbers had to do w/ magnets? why yes, there was! I wonder who the genius was that thought that up? Oh yeah, ME! TWO of my theroies are now plausible thanx to just ONE episode! Sorry for bragging & all, but i just can't help it :D

[sleepwalker]

LOL. For me, all this confirmed was that Hurley has the most pointless episodes.

It was like some whacked out crossover-fic between Fight Club and the Buffy episode "Normal Again". Except with the solution for Hurley to kill himself, not everyone else.

*erases episode from mind*

[ProphecyBoy]

Libby isn't necessarily a "psycho". She may have had genuine mental health problems. Doesn't make her crazy or evil.

A nice episode. Hurley episodes are always good. Dark humoured.

The island is REAL...the events that are happening are REAL. The producers have confimed that what we are seeing is not a dream, a hallucination or "purgatory". That would just be a cop-out and to be honest I don't think the makers of the show would stoop so low.

Better than Buffy's episode Normal Again and way a thousand times better than Charmed's episode Brain Drain.

[cirestan]

IF Libby really did have some type of medical background (could tie in with Jack or Kate's boyfriend doctor) maybe she got depressed by losing too many patients (Oncology) and that is why she was in the Psych ward. (And I could have sworn I saw her in the background during the first take (when Dave was there) of the Connect Four scene.

So she COULD be relatively normal.

I knew that the hatch was a joke when the clock ran out on Locke and nothing happened. Who would have set up a system that hits zero but then still had time to reset before anything REALLY happened?

The best part of the episode (I agree) was when everyone was standing around laughing at Sawyer getting his A$$ kicked by Hurley. Especially when he started crawling out from under the tarp and got pulled back in like a cartoon.

Does everyone else realize that with every passing episode our attention is drawn farther and farther from the biggest mysteries of the island? The Black Cloud, The Black Rock, The Polar Bear, the 20 foot tidal surge that swallowed the plane wreckage.

[GetLost]

Ummm ok gotta make this quick but like Henry or what ever his name is lied numerous times about stuff such as his name, story, and just about everything. Ok he now confronts Locke that he NEVER put in the code and that the hatch just reset itsself automatically.

This my friends could either be...

A: The truth

B: Another one of his lies inorder to get the losties to have a REAL lockdown in the hatch and be injured or hurt or destroyed. Hmm think about it.. If i was strapped in a hostile place and had the chance to coax everyone that it really did nothing but actually exploded or something. I would do it.

I find Henry to be an outcast of the Others and they abandoned him or he was kicked out for somereason.

Libby in the psyce ward? WTH much confusion and she has ties to the numbers also most likely.. wana see Libby centric soon.

Also whole Dave issue was obvious .. Good epi though.. gotta run