React to 2.12 "Fire + Water"

[Sydney]

React to "Fire + Water"

Tell us what you loved, hated, liked, etc.

To vote you must be a member.

Not a Member?
Register Here


:boat: http://www.lookinglost.net
:pirate: http://www.lostforum.org

[Lost4ever]

It was the BEST episode EVER!!!

[Kilroy]

Friggin' Locke. What a hypocrite. Where does he get off, hitting Charlie. Especially considering his assault on Sayid.

Not that Charlie is smelling all that good either. He is practically a psycho: Shooting Ethan was only the start, it seems. He's got an obsessive personality.

Kudoes for Hurley, though. And I am proud of Jack.

[sleepwalker]

Second half? Worse ever. But completely worth it to see Dom shirtless that many times in forty minutes.

ps.
the numbers are taking over the world

lolol I love Veronica Mars. Even if that episode made no sense whatsoever.

[~ LOST Fairy ~]

The episode was ok. I mean it was really good, and I loved the flashbacks but some of the stuff was just so out there.

I felt really bad for Charlie almost the whole episode :(

ERR I can't believe the way Locke punched him! He needed friggin' stitches!!!! I'm really ticked at Locker right now, think I might just start calling him the stupid bald wanker from now on- side note: I really liked when Charlie said that, made me giggle hehe.

Aww Hurley is so cute in that episode! But did anyone else notice that Libby kinda freaked out a bit more than what would be considered normal when Hurley asked her if he knew her from somewhere and that she looked familar? Cuz I thought her little cover story about him stepping on her feet on the plane sounded fishy...

[HarVardGrl92]

OMG pretty good episode.
I loved hurley/libby scenes, and when Hurley was asking about Libby. It was so cute!

I hate Locke for punching Charlie! And I hate Liam for getting Charlie on drugs in the 1st place!

[JackRocksHard]

I think all in all, the episode was pretty good. The flashbacks were really good, but the "present" things were a little disappointing.
I felt bad for Charlie at first when he woke up from his "sleep kidnapping" because really, he didn't know what he was doing. But everything after that? What the hell was he thinking? I didnt really think Id ever say this, but I sure hope he was on drugs. Thats the only rationalization I can see for doing things that would clearly alienate him from everyone on the island. I love Charlie as much as the next guy, but come on.
On another note, I dont see why everyone's so down on Locke. If I was on the island and some delusional drug addict (former or otherwise) was kidnapping babies, hes the guy I would want to have around. Charile went out of his way to make himself a threat, and I think Locke handled it perfectly. To be honest, I thought he was going to punch Charlie as soon as he got the baby. He had it coming, and it kinda makes sense given the severity of what Charlie was doing despite several warnings to stop.
Now we get to wait for a few weeks until another new episode. yay. Anyone else remember when TV shows used to... I dunno... play a full season of episodes?

[LOST_2005]

Charlie is an idiot. FULL STOP

I love Locke for hitting Charlie. He should of hit him more than three times though.

Jack is just a loser, as if Charlie would need stitches for that little cut.

Sawyer is awsome, Hurley and Libby are looking alrite.

All in all good episode. I give this one 7.9/10

[ObsessedWithSawyer13]

LIBBY+HURLEY=lurley? hibby?they both do not sound good. oh well

I HATE LOCKE! h8 h8 h8 h8 h8 h8 h8 h8 h8! i feel so bad 4 charlie! even tho he was acting just a little bit crazy(sarcasm intended). liam is such a jerk. he wasn't even there 2 see his own kid! u can not get much lower.

[dam_on25]

I do feel that the story is moving along much too slowly. I mean, we've had flash backs for almost one and a half seasons now, but we still ain't got any freaking clues about the others, the island, the french lady etc.

Of course I'm not asking all the answers to be given in a few episodes, but how about throwing us some crumbs ya?

But either way, this episode is still pretty good... :)