The "Man" Kate love??

[Sawyer's girls]

In what ever the case may be , Kate told Jack that the toy airplane, she took out of the case, belong to the man she love...and she killed him.

I was wondering who could it be?

I think the man Kate is refering to is her father. she once told Jack her father was in the "military" , he might have been a fighter pilot..or something of that nature. so i think the man she kill could be her father.

what do you think?

..also Sawyer was the second person to warn Jack about Kate. Sawyer seem like he might know Kate , or knew of her, or why would he make a statement like that, about someone you just met? did anyone stop to think that Kate's boyfriend/the robber might have been Sawyer's brother? or friend ( I say brother, because they have very similar features)

Very interesting theory
i like it

[Evangeline_Freak]

I like it 2!

[Evangeline_Freak]

I don't think she killed her father, even though we do know he is dead. No one is that horrible, plus, I think she killed her boyfriend. 'm not positive, though, so please don't act like I'm a genius! :lol2:

[ilovelost]

[color=red]I think she killed her father :(

[Kipper]

Originally posted by Sawyer's girls@Jan 6 2005, 03:14 PM
did anyone stop to think that Kate's boyfriend/the robber might have been Sawyer's brother? ( I say brother, because they have very similar features)

Hey, I caught that too, the similar feature thing. At first, I almost mistook him for Sawyer, I kinda had to look twice....I like this theory!!! very kewl 'Girls!!

I don't think it was her father though, because of the way she says 'the man I love' and her reaction, it's more of a love of her life thing rather than father/daughter.

[Evangeline_Freak]

Originally posted by ilovelost@Mar 17 2005, 04:12 PM
[color=red]I think she killed her father :(

Why would she do something as horrible as that? Kate's the best!!!!

[Sawyer's girls]

Why would she do something as horrible as that? Kate's the best!!!!

..maybe she did it indirectly...( if at all, it could be a another guy, but the plane,made me think of her father) ..like prehaps she did something that cause her father's death, like fake a kiddnappeing, or rob his place of business, and her partner shot him, or something like that.

[HarVardGrl92]

nice theories!